Over the past two decades, human feet—often still inside their shoes—have washed up on beaches along the northwestern Pacific coast of the United States and Canada. The origins of these eerie discoveries seem linked to advances in athletic footwear technology.
It all began on August 20, 2007. A twelve-year-old girl visiting Jedediah Island with her father made a macabre discovery on the shore: a human foot still in its sock, tucked inside a black-and-white Adidas athletic sneaker. A few days later, on August 26, a couple uncovered a similar find on Gabriola Island, British Columbia (Canada). There again, it was a human foot still inside a sporting shoe, this time branded Reebok.
Since then, discoveries have followed one after another, sometimes on Valdes, Kirkland, or Westham islands in Canada, and at other times along the coast of Washington State in the United States, just a few miles further south. Since 2007, about fifteen human feet have been found, most often in sports footwear. How can these events be explained?
Victims of Tsunamis, Plane Crashes or a Serial Killer?
Many theories have been proposed over the years. Some suggested a maritime or aerial catastrophe, notably the 2005 aircraft crash on Quadra Island, where all four occupants were never recovered. This line of inquiry was quickly abandoned. Others proposed that these human remains could come from victims of the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami. Again, that explanation did not hold for long. And indeed, some individuals identified by their DNA turn out to be local victims. Finally, some have floated the serial killer theory. Yet, to date, no criminal origin has been proven.
Of the fourteen feet recovered along the coast over the years, coroner Barb McLintocken identified ten as belonging to seven individuals. The other feet, two of which could belong to the same person, were too degraded to enable identification. Still, according to her, the causes of death were either suicides or accidents. For their part, the forensic anthropologists working with the coroner found no signs of trauma.
Why Only the Feet?
When a body ends up at sea, it sinks to the ocean floor before being picked at by scavengers. Most scavengers are fairly lazy and will prefer to attack the softer parts of the body. And in humans, the soft parts include the ankles, composed mainly of soft tissue and ligaments. Or, if you gnaw at an ankle, the foot will eventually detach before major decomposition sets in.
Shoes That Are Getting Lighter
As to why the phenomenon really began to manifest only around 2007, Barb McLintock points to the evolution of the athletic footwear industry. In recent decades, sneakers have indeed been made from lighter materials. Moreover, some pairs feature air pockets inside the insoles. Consequently, athletic shoes tend to float more readily.
In other words, other feet—and their shoes—likely detached from their bodies in the years prior to the first discovery. But at the time, they simply sank to the bottom of the ocean. Another explanation suggested concerns the region’s particular sea currents. The waters off the northwest Pacific are known for their strong currents, capable of transporting objects and debris over long distances. It is possible that once detached from the rest of the body, the feet were carried away by these currents, which would explain why they all end up ashore in the same geographic area. The buoyancy of modern footwear would then allow these feet to stay at the surface until they are finally deposited on the beaches.