How many times have you left a film thinking, “Meh”? Not entirely bad, not quite good either. Just… forgettable. You’re not alone. More and more viewers share this diffuse sense that contemporary cinema — especially Hollywood — is stuck in a loop. Yet these films tick all the boxes: bankable stars, spectacular special effects, a smoothly oiled narrative structure. So why do they fail to move us anymore? The answer might lie in the science of storytelling, in cognitive psychology… and in the logic of platforms.
When Films Become “Passable”
In a video that has become a landmark, the essayist Evan Puschak (aka The Nerdwriter) delivered a critique that hits home: Hollywood’s real problem isn’t so much bad films as films that are merely “passable.”
Among these reference figures, you’ll find Robert McKee and Blake Snyder, whose books have influenced generations of screenwriters. They propose a grid that is almost mathematical in its approach to storytelling: evoke the audience’s empathy from the first minutes, trigger a decisive event before you reach page 27 of the script, structure the tale into three clearly defined acts… In theory, this method is foolproof.
And yet, many films that apply it to the letter fail to move us. Why?
Our Brains Already Know the Formula
Neuroscience and cognitive psychology can help us understand this phenomenon. The human brain is naturally drawn to well-structured narratives: they activate neural networks tied to attention, memory, and emotion. That is why ancient myths or Greek tragedies have endured for centuries: they obey a powerful narrative machinery.
But this mechanism, when repeated too often, becomes predictable. The human brain, while sensitive to structure, also craves surprise and novelty. When it anticipates every twist, every line of dialogue, every ending, it disengages. The result: a diffuse sense of boredom, even with a production that is perfectly calibrated.
This is sometimes referred to in psychology as the “cognitive satiation effect”: what once gave pleasure eventually tires, because it no longer stimulates curiosity or emotion.
Movies That Resemble Algorithms
This phenomenon is amplified by streaming platforms. Netflix, Disney+ or HBO Max continuously analyze the tastes of their subscribers and produce films that optimize click-through rates, retention, or “re-watch” metrics. In other words: content designed to appeal to everyone… thus to no one in particular.
Communication researchers speak of an “industrialization of taste”: in chasing maximal consensus, we end up with smooth, unremarkable works. Films that seem as if they were generated by artificial intelligence: efficient, but soulless.
When Fiction No Longer Speaks to Reality
Another consequence: modern films talk less and less about real life. According to Puschak, they no longer draw on human experience, but… on other films. They are “metareferential,” self-replicating, as if cinema were copying itself to infinity. We find the same archetypes, the same plots, the same formulas.
This aligns with a critique voiced by screenwriter and director Charlie Kaufman (Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Adaptation). For him, the obsession with structure kills authenticity. In his public appearances, he stresses the importance of “saying who you are,” speaking from within, even in a disorderly way. For what moves us are not the mechanics, but human truths.
Can We Measure This Artistic Decline?
Of course, aesthetic perception is subjective. It’s difficult to “scientifically prove” that a film is good or bad. But one can still observe measurable trends:
-
Decrease in the vocabulary used in dialogue;
-
Reduction in the number of long takes in favor of rapid editing;
-
Narrative recycling (remakes, sequels, reboots);
-
Less diversity in the profiles of characters and creators.
Data science researchers have already mapped these evolutions. The thematic variety of American cinema has fallen by 30% over twenty years, according to a 2020 study in Nature Communications. The blame lies with the search for a “winning model” to replicate.
Hope Comes from the Margins
All is not lost. The rise of streaming has also allowed some authors to express themselves freely, at least for a while. Charlie Kaufman, the Safdie brothers, Ari Aster or Chloé Zhao were able to make demanding films, thanks to platforms willing to take risks.
But this golden age seems already receding. Netflix recently announced plans to curb “auteur projects” deemed unprofitable. A return to a standardized blockbuster logic is already underway.